If the Rangers could score the next goal, MSGN announcer Sam Rosen said late in the second period after the Rangers scored what would prove to be their lone goal of the night, they could realistically make a game of it. This despite having spotted the LA Kings a 3-0 lead with a dreadful, inexcusable, unforgiveable 25 minutes of listless, chaotic, undisciplined play to start the game. That got me thinking. With the kind of firepower the Rangers have on their first two lines, with Jaromir Jagr leading the league in overall scoring (18 points) and assists (15) despite playing with a weak shoulder and Brendan Shanahan co-leading the league with ten goals in eleven games, it was easy to imagine them scoring that goal and one or two more to maybe even pull out this game.
But what was even more imaginable was the Rangers' awful defense allowing the offensively challenged Kings a chance to put them away by scoring the next goal themselves -- whoa! I was in the middle of that very thought when Sean Avery of all people swept a shot past Henrik Lundqvist despite the presence of two defenders to drive the final nail in the Rangers' coffin and complete the scoring in a 4-1 Ranger loss that was never as close as that score would indicate. And that made moot an earlier thought I had -- that it was already too late to salvage anything other than a point or two, even if the Rangers were able to regroup and pull that point or two out, that's how bad their approach to this game was.
Four goals to a team that was averaging less than two per game and had managed only 14 goals in going 1-7-2 over their last ten games, only six goals during the five game losing streak they brought into this game. One goal against a team that had allowed 29 goals during that ten game stretch and 16 during their five game losing streak. Unimaginable, one would think, especially with the team feeling so good about themselves after their 7-3 drubbing of Phoenix that they eschewed a game-day skate in favor of a leisurely bike ride in warm and sunny Santa Monica (supply your own punch line here if you think the final score wasn't enough of a punch to the gut).
We've seen this before -- a team that feels too good about itself after an easy win over a team in disarray that is not even NHL caliber, a team that feels they can win just by showing up for the next game against a rebuilding team with a record nearly as bad, a team that feels it has to play its high-priced veterans like Marek Malik and some of his fellow defensemen over young players like Thomas Pöck who can at least bring energy to the ice while faring no worse, a team that feels it has to stick with failed personnel decisions like trading for the totally unproductive Marcel Hossa when talented young players like Nigel Dawes are chomping at the bit to get that same chance and prove something.
We've seen seven years' worth of that before, and we were under the impression that we would not see that again after the fire sale of 2004 and last season's youth-inflected renaissance built on consistent work ethic, systems play, and attention to detail. So even if it's still early, even if this team has enough talent to come together when it counts next spring, it's time to start pointing some fingers and demand action before it's too late for next spring to matter even if things do eventually gel.
Well, first let's eliminate the guys we're not going to point fingers at. Shanahan, obviously, who not only scored the team's lone goal on his team-leading seven shots on goal, but who also dove to make defensive plays -- of all the high-priced overage free agent ex-superstars brought in over the years, this guy is clearly not in that class, his superlative efforts so far being wasted. Ryan Hollweg is immune from criticism -- he is still a hitter and a sparkplug, and despite a lack of points can advance the attack and backcheck too. Petr Prucha, despite not getting the opportunities at either even strength or the power play, is nevertheless far ahead of last season, when he was lightly used in New York or in Hartford at this juncture.
And despite their poor showing in this particular game (due in part to not getting any ice time early when the Kings were handed five first period power plays), it's hard to point fingers at the top line -- Jagr is amazingly piling up points while still not 100%, Martin Straka is converting set-up passes like he wasn't able to last season (six goals to date), and though he is not a true number one center and is prone to turnover, Michael Nylander is in the top ten in league scoring and, at +6, is not among the top culprits in compiling the NHL's third-worst defense.
On the blue line, you have to say the same about Aaron Ward and Fedor Tyutin, a tandem on defense for much of the season so far, even though, as Ward said last week, being the least worst on defense is nothing to be proud of. The truth is, Ward is doing well for a guy who was never considered more than a physical presence on the second or third defensive pair throughout his career -- he is remarkably leading the team at +7, is even more remarkably leading Ranger defensemen in scoring (he is fifth overall on the team with seven points), and is tied for fifth in the NHL with 34 hits. And Tyutin, still a promising young sophomore, may have work to do in both ends of the ice, especially in developing consistency, but his decent numbers in every relevant category -- points, +/-, hits, blocked shots -- reflect the reality that he is in fact developing and has not been the problem.
So where do the fingers point? Start with the remainder of the defense. Malik has been the worst, with his turnovers (three on one shift last night), his getting regularly beaten by quick young forwards, and his infuriating response to that, taking costly hooking penalties instead of using the body. What has changed for Malik in one season? Last season, his nimble stickwork and footwork jump started many a Ranger rush or stopped opposition attacks -- just a few months later, both skills look slow as molasses and his insistence of using them is hurting the team tremendously. How can a guy deteriorate so quickly?
Well, one reason is that his defense partner, Michal Rozsival, is playing nearly as bad, mainly due to poor decision making rather than lack of skill. Another reason is that support from up front, from the defensive forwards, is not there this season like it was last season. The value of Jed Ortmeyer and Dominic Moore as energetic defensively-minded fourth line forwards is no longer in question because of their lack of point production as it was during the off-season. Blair Betts and Jason Ward need to be reunited to make the most of their chemistry -- Betts is useless as a second liner, unable to pick up even an accidental assist while skating with a goal machine like Shanahan and a speedster like Matt Cullen, and his face-off work is sub-par this season, while Ward is more effective on the right wing than in the pivot of a makeshift unit.
Cullen and Adam Hall are not playing poorly -- both are on a nearly exact pace to duplicate their regular season numbers of last season, 25 goals and 50 points for Cullen, 15 goals and 30 points for Hall, with similar +/- numbers (plus for Cullen, minus for Hall), and with Cullen making good use of his speed and Hall of his size. But the Rangers need more than that from both of them -- Cullen needs to play more like he did in Carolina's playoff run and Hall needs to have a breakout season for the Rangers to step up. Hossa, despite playing a noticeably more energetic game, remains essentially useless, with zero points, and somehow managing to go -7 in limited minutes. Dawes could hardly do worse -- in fact, has done better in even less playing time.
Back to the defense: Karel Rachunek, scratched for a second straight game, has been a detriment on defense (team worst -9) while adding no offense (one point in nine games) despite significant power play time; Darius Kasparaitis has either not recovered from his off-season health problems or is just not going to be the same player he used to be; and Sandis Ozolinsh has quietly gone -4 in his three games back even though the Rangers are 2-1-0 in those games -- he has been on the ice for an incredible seven of ten goals against in his three games, but only three of twelve goals for.
Then there is Lundqvist. Last season, the overachieving defense and young role playing forwards were said to benefit from his work in net. If he is not himself this season, then that might explain why a mediocre defense is looking, well, mediocre, or worse, even though no one is trying to make that case. So it may in fact be as much of a case of Lundqvist not getting adequate support as anything else. Last season he got a lot of credit for the way he controlled rebounds -- but I always thought the key was the way the defense controlled those rebounds. That's not happening this season -- neither is the defense's ability to control opposition rushes or their set play from the point or down low.
Sure, Lundqvist is giving up uncharacteristically easy goals like Brent Sopel's second goal last night or Avery's killer fourth goal. But the former came after a mad scramble on a lengthy five on three, with the penalty killing and possibly Lundqvist discombobulated, and the latter shot would not have been possible without inexcusably lax defense. This is not to excuse Lundqvist, but to suggest that the mix of quality and quantity of shots that he is facing, combined with shocking breakdowns in team defense, are putting him in a position where more of those types of goals happen.
All of which brings us to the coach. At this point in time, he has to hold himself and his staff accountable for the defensive breakdowns. And for the misuse of personnel, like having Betts on the second line, Ward at center, and Prucha on the third line, and for the continued use of Hossa and Malik ahead of Dawes and Pöck. And for the team's inability to summon the chemistry, work ethic, and attention to detail that were the hallmark of his Adams Trophy candidacy a season ago. This is not a call for Renney's head -- he has the tools, the talent, and the time to bring it back together. But he must find a way to muster his troops before he runs out of time.
Rangers roasted in today's papers for their dismal effort -- see the News, Newsday, and Post, plus a prescient pre-game report from Newsday. Game report from NY Sports Day. NYR.com's game recap is an interesting exercise in spin cycling, giving the Kings too much credit for taking advantage of their flawed and listless opponent. LA area reports from their Times and News, and the Orange County Register. Plenty of interesting observations by the beat writers in their blogs -- Sam Weinman watching from back here in Rangers Report and Steve Zipay from the West Coast in Blue Notes. Hockey Rodent has a spot on economic analysis of why it doesn't make sense to stick with high-priced vets just because of their contracts, a lesson the Rangers need to re-learn after their one year hiatus from their seven years of bad luck.
In a lone bit of prospect news, Brodie Dupont extended his point scoring streak to eleven games in Calgary's win last night, assisting on the game winning goal. USA Hockey's college hockey poll for this week has Billy Ryan's Maine Black Bears in the top spot again by unanimous vote. BU (Kenny Roche) dropped four spots to #8 because of their loss to UMass-Lowell, Michigan Tech (Jordan Foote) moved into the top 15, Harvard (Dylan Reese) drops out of the top 15, and NMU (Darin Olver) remains among the other nine schools receiving consideration. Maine was nearly but not quite unanimous number one in the latest poll from USCHO. BU dropped to #7 there, while Harvard, Michigan Tech, and NMU placed 16, 18, and 19 respectively, with Tech entering this list for the first time after their weekend sweep of Alaska-Anchorage.